Understanding When an Option to Tax Is Needed: A Practical Guide for Property Owners
Many commercial property owners and landlords assume that VAT planning ends with registration — but that is often not the case when it comes to land and buildings.
In the UK, supplies of land and buildings are normally exempt from VAT. That means:
No VAT is charged on sales or rents
VAT incurred on acquisition, refurbishment or ongoing costs typically cannot be reclaimed
This can result in significant hidden costs unless you consider the Option to Tax.
In this guide, we explain when an Option to Tax is relevant, what it covers, and the key points to consider — particularly for commercial property owners, developers and investors.
What Is an Option to Tax?
An Option to Tax is a formal election that allows you to treat the supply of your land or buildings as standard-rated for VAT purposes rather than exempt.
Once exercised:
VAT is charged on supplies (such as rents or sales) you make of your interest in the property
You can normally recover VAT on related costs, including purchase VAT, professional fees, renovation and maintenance expenses
For VAT purposes, the term “land” includes buildings or structures permanently affixed to the land. Importantly, you do not have to own the freehold to opt — leaseholders can also make the election.
What Are You Actually Opting to Tax?
When you opt to tax, you can specify either a building or land.
If you specify a building:
The election continues to apply even if the building is demolished
It will automatically apply to any future buildings erected on the same land
If you specify land:
It applies to the land and any existing buildings
It also applies to any future buildings constructed on that land
In both cases, it is possible to exclude new buildings from the Option to Tax if required, but this must be carefully structured and properly documented.
How Do You Opt to Tax?
Opting to tax is not automatic and is not achieved solely through VAT registration.
You must:
Submit a completed Form VAT1614A to HMRC
Ensure the notification is signed by an authorised signatory
Notify HMRC within 30 days of the decision to opt
If you miss the 30-day window, HMRC may accept a late notification, but you will need to provide evidence that the decision was made at the relevant time. This might include correspondence with third parties referring to the option or documentation showing VAT being charged in accordance with the election.
Why Would You Opt to Tax?
The primary reason is input VAT recovery.
Without an Option to Tax:
VAT on purchase and development costs cannot usually be reclaimed
Significant VAT may become an irrecoverable cost
With an Option to Tax:
You can reclaim VAT on qualifying expenditure
Development or refurbishment projects may become financially viable
However, electing to tax also means that rent and lease income will be subject to VAT. This may increase costs for tenants who cannot fully recover VAT, and could affect the commercial attractiveness of the property.
Careful planning is essential before making the election.
Who Is Bound by the Option to Tax?
If you are not part of a VAT group:
Only your supplies of the opted land or building are affected
The election does not transfer automatically when you sell the property
A tenant who sub-lets must decide independently whether to opt
It is good practice to inform tenants of your decision at an early stage so they can assess their own VAT position.
If you are, or later become, part of a VAT group, your Option to Tax may bind other group members as relevant associates. This can have wider VAT implications across the group and should be reviewed carefully.
Common Pitfalls
Revoking During the Cooling-Off Period
If you make an Option to Tax with the intention of revoking it within the six-month cooling-off period, HMRC may treat the election as invalid from the outset.
Scope Misunderstandings
Linked buildings or complexes grouped around an enclosed concourse may be treated as a single building for VAT purposes.
Tenant Impact
Failing to consider whether tenants can recover VAT may lead to commercial difficulties later.
When Is an Option to Tax Required?
An Option to Tax is rarely legally mandatory. It is typically a strategic commercial decision.
It often becomes necessary in practice when:
Significant VAT has been incurred on purchase or development
You wish to recover VAT on refurbishment or construction
Your tenant or purchaser is VAT-registered and expects a taxable supply
You should proceed with caution where:
Tenants are unable to recover VAT
Future plans for the property are uncertain
You are part of a VAT group and unsure of the wider consequences
When an Option to Tax Is Not Required
An Option to Tax is not always necessary, even where a business is VAT registered.
In particular, an Option to Tax is generally not required where the building is used solely within your own VAT-registered business, rather than being rented out or sold.
For example:
A trading company purchases a commercial property to use as its own office or operational premises
The business is VAT registered and makes fully taxable supplies
The property is not intended to be let to third parties or sold as an exempt supply
In these circumstances, VAT incurred on the purchase, refurbishment and running costs of the building is normally recoverable as input tax without opting to tax, because the costs are directly attributable to taxable business activities.
This is a key point that is often misunderstood. Businesses sometimes assume an Option to Tax is required simply to reclaim VAT on a property purchase, when in fact recovery may already be available through normal VAT principles.
Final Thoughts
An Option to Tax can be a powerful VAT planning tool, but it carries long-term consequences. The decision affects pricing, tenant relationships, recovery of input tax and potentially other entities within a VAT group.
Before opting to tax, it is important to review both the immediate VAT recovery benefits and the longer-term commercial impact.
If you are purchasing, developing, leasing or selling commercial property and are unsure whether an Option to Tax is appropriate, obtaining specialist advice can prevent costly mistakes and ensure the election is handled correctly from the outset.
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and does not constitute tax advice. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and may change.
Get in touch:
📧 hello@surreyhillstax.co.uk
📞 01483 970 410